Insulin Resistance Changes Everything - The Hidden Driver of Weight Gain, Inflammation, and Thyroid Dysfunction with Dr. Alessia Roehnelt

Insulin Resistance, Thyroid Health, and the Metabolic Domino Effect

Why catching insulin issues early can change your long-term health trajectory

Insulin resistance is no longer just a diabetes conversation. It is a full-body, long-term health issue that affects thyroid function, inflammation, fertility, cardiovascular risk, and overall metabolic resilience.

In a powerful episode of the Modern Thyroid and Wellness podcast, host McCall McPherson sits down with endocrinologist Alessia Roehnelt to unpack what insulin resistance really is, why it develops so quietly, and how it connects directly to thyroid dysfunction and chronic inflammation.

This conversation reframes insulin as one of the most important predictors of long-term health outcomes, not just blood sugar.

Insulin Resistance Explained Simply

Insulin’s job is to move glucose from your bloodstream into your cells so it can be used for energy. When insulin resistance develops, the body needs more and more insulin to do the same job. Over time, this creates a constant high-insulin state.

That chronic elevation matters because insulin is not just a blood sugar hormone. It is also:

• A fat-storage hormone
  
• A pro-inflammatory signal
  
• A disruptor of hormone balance when chronically elevated
  

Eventually, the system burns out. Blood sugar rises, inflammation increases, and the risk of prediabetes and type 2 diabetes climbs.

The key insight from Dr. Roehnelt is this:
Insulin resistance starts years before diabetes ever appears on labs.

The Red Flags Most People Miss

One of the most telling early signs of insulin resistance is rapid, dramatic weight fluctuation.

Patients often say things like:

• “I gain 5 to 10 pounds in a weekend.”
  
• “I eat well all week, but one higher-carb meal sets me back completely.”
  

This is not imagined. It is a metabolic response.

When insulin spikes, the body shifts into fat-storage mode for the entire day. Even nutrient-dense meals eaten later are more likely to be stored rather than used efficiently.

Another physical sign clinicians look for is acanthosis nigricans, a darkened, velvety discoloration often seen on the back of the neck, which is strongly associated with insulin resistance.

The Thyroid–Insulin Feedback Loop

One of the most important takeaways from this episode is the bidirectional relationship between insulin and thyroid hormones.

• Hypothyroidism can drive insulin resistance by slowing metabolism.
  
• Insulin resistance increases inflammation, which interferes with thyroid hormone conversion and absorption.
  
• Chronic inflammation can worsen autoimmune thyroid conditions like Hashimoto’s.
  

Treating only one side of this equation often leaves patients stuck. Sustainable improvement happens when both insulin sensitivity and thyroid optimization are addressed together.

Why “Normal” Labs Are Not the Same as Optimal

A recurring theme in the conversation is the danger of waiting for labs to become “abnormal.”

Examples discussed:

• Fasting glucose in the high 90s is often labeled normal, yet it signals early dysfunction.
  
• Insulin levels in the upper end of the lab range may still indicate insulin resistance when paired with normal glucose.
  
• Hemoglobin A1c values near 5.6 are technically normal, but already trending toward prediabetes.
  

Lab reference ranges often reflect an already unhealthy population. Optimal health requires earlier intervention, not reactive treatment.

Labs That Matter Most

According to Dr. Roehnelt, the most informative early markers include:

• Fasting insulin (truly fasting, water only)
  
• Fasting glucose
  
• Hemoglobin A1c
  
• Liver enzymes (AST and ALT)
  
• Full thyroid panel with antibodies
  
• Vitamin D levels
  

These labs together reveal patterns that no single marker can show on its own.

First-Line Strategies That Actually Work

Before medications are considered, three foundational interventions make the biggest difference:

1. Sleep
Poor sleep raises cortisol, which raises blood sugar and insulin. Consistent, quality sleep is non-negotiable for metabolic repair.

2. Strength Training
Muscle is one of the most powerful tools for improving insulin sensitivity. Resistance training outperforms cardio alone for long-term metabolic health.

3. Carbohydrate Quality and Pairing
Reducing refined starches and sugars while pairing carbohydrates with protein and fat helps blunt insulin spikes and improve glucose control.

When Medications Enter the Conversation

Medications are not a failure. They are tools.

Dr. Roehnelt explains how she approaches them:

• Metformin is often a first step. It improves insulin sensitivity, is well-studied, inexpensive, and does not cause hypoglycemia.
  
• GLP-1 medications are considered when lifestyle changes are not enough or when organ damage and inflammation are already present.
  

Beyond weight loss, GLP-1 therapies show promise for reducing inflammation, improving autoimmune symptoms, and supporting long-term metabolic health when used appropriately.

The Bigger Picture

Insulin resistance is not a willpower problem. It is a biological signal.

Many people are metabolically disadvantaged long before they realize it. Tools like continuous glucose monitoring, early lab interpretation, and personalized interventions level the playing field so effort finally translates into results.

As this episode makes clear, early awareness and proactive care can prevent years of frustration and future disease.

‍